Search Here

The Los Angeles Unified School District has decided to ban the use of cellphones and social media by students during the school day.

The Ban Details

The Board of Education for the Los Angeles Unified School District voted 5-2 in favor of developing a policy that will prohibit student use of cellphones and social media platforms during the entire school day. The policy, scheduled to take effect in January, aims to benefit the district's 429,000 students. Board member Nick Melvoin, who proposed the resolution, believes this policy will positively impact both students and the broader community.

Why Los Angeles Schools Want to Ban Cellphones

Educators have long struggled with the issue of cellphone distractions in classrooms. A Pew Research Center survey from fall 2023 revealed that one-third of K-12 teachers in the United States consider phone distractions a major problem. This ban is intended to reduce distractions and protect students' mental health. California Governor Gavin Newsom supports these efforts and has previously signed legislation that allowed districts to limit or ban smartphone use in schools. Newsom, echoing US Surgeon General Vivek Murthy, highlighted the mental health concerns linked to social media, calling it a mental health emergency for young people.

Implementation Challenges

Implementing the ban will require practical solutions for cellphone storage during school hours, such as locked pouches or lockers. The policy must also consider age-appropriate guidelines and exceptions for students with learning or physical disabilities. The current policy, adopted in 2011, already prohibits cellphone use during school hours, excluding lunch and nutrition breaks. The new ban will expand on this, covering the entire school day.

Mixed Reactions

The ban has elicited mixed reactions from administrators, parents, and students. Concerns include student ownership, safety, communication, and the practicalities of enforcement. Board members George McKenna and Scott Schmerelson voted against the resolution, citing concerns about its restrictiveness and enforcement challenges. 

Schmerelson noted that managing this policy could become a full-time job for school staff. However, supporters argue that similar policies have improved learning environments in other schools within the district.

Broader Context

Nationally, there is growing concern over the impact of cellphones on young people's mental health and learning environments. Over 76% of K-12 public schools prohibited cellphone use in non-academic settings as of the 2021-2022 school year. Several states, including Florida, Indiana, and Ohio, have passed legislation restricting cellphone use in schools. Lawmakers in at least eight other states are considering similar measures, reflecting a broader trend to address the influence of smartphones on student well-being and academic performance.